After Gov. Andy Beshear ordered schools across Kentucky to close in the wake of spiking COVID-19 cases, Warren County Public Schools Superintendent Rob Clayton vowed his district will continue to push for in-person classes.

Warren County Board of Education member Amy Duvall lamented the demise of “local control,” and Clayton indicated school officials were caught off-guard by Beshear’s announcement Wednesday.

“Although we received no information prior to the governor’s press conference (Wednesday) afternoon, we have long recognized that the governor had the authority to implement an executive order, which carries the same authority as law,” Clayton wrote Thursday in a district message to parents.

That pattern will hold for elementary school students until at least Dec. 7, and even then, if Warren County is still in the red with its virus incidence rate, schools won’t reopen.

Middle school students – sixth grade included – and high school students won’t return to their classrooms until at least Jan. 4 under Beshear’s order.

Clayton also outlined potential consequences if schools defy the governor’s order to shift to virtual learning beginning Monday.

“Jason Glass, Kentucky Department of Education commissioner, indicated during a conference call (Wednesday) afternoon that he would remove any superintendent or board member who did not comply with the governor’s order,” Clayton wrote Thursday. “Despite this mandate, please know that we will continue advocating for in-person instruction because we understand firsthand how critical this is for so many of our students.”

Speaking during a school board meeting Thursday, Clayton told families to be prepared for the possibility of extended school closures.

“We do need to be prepared for an extended period of virtual learning,” Clayton said. “I’m not trying to predict the future, but it’s very clear to me that there’s a likely possibility that we would remain in the red category. … The reality is that could continue for some time, and there’s not a lot we can do as a school organization.”

Clayton said the district has seen “no students that have been quarantined in these 58 days since Aug. 24 that have a confirmed case of the virus.”

“We’ve had no students be hospitalized as a result of contracting the virus,” barring one staff member who was briefly hospitalized, Clayton said.

“I’m proud to say she’s already reported back to work a couple of weeks ago. And again, we have no evidence to even suggest that the virus has been spread during the school day student-to-student,” Clayton said.

Clayton said the district is continuing to plan for an eventual reopening. “There still will be an update Dec. 1,” he said. “It’s probably going to look a bit different.”

Warren County school board Chairman Kerry Young sympathized with the difficult position some parents now find themselves in, particularly the parents of a sixth grader who can no longer attend the same school as their younger sibling.

“No matter the configuration of your district, the state is going to operate K-5 and 6-12,” Young said.

Board member Lloyd Williford said he sees WCPS as a “beacon” for other school districts across the state to emulate in its response to the coronavirus pandemic. “I do not like to be surprised, and that’s just the way things have happened,” Williford said.

Duvall said “we are being locked down” under the state order. She said students are being harmed by not being in school, and that there isn’t evidence to show schools being open drives increases in COVID-19 cases.

“Schools are not a significant contributor to community spread. Listen to science,” Duvall said.

– Follow education reporter Aaron Mudd on Twitter @BGDN_edbeat or visit

– Follow education reporter Aaron Mudd on Twitter @BGDN_edbeat or visit

Education reporter. Covers education and related issues, focusing primarily on the Bowling Green and Warren County public school districts and Western Kentucky University.

(2) comments

Dr. Strangelove

King Beshear could do this every year hyping flu cases. Even though we know ages under 50 are exponentially less risk to die than those over 60. Such BS. All the families that are being hit by far greater economic effects from using such ridiculous standards and definitions. So, let's take it further, and apply it to only government workers and the Governor with no pay. Let none of them come out of isolation until NO ONE EVER DIES in this country! King Beshear's dummy comment that the virus wasn't being fair is as naïve as it gets. A crook, idiot and Democrat, All synonyms for the same thing.

Parameter Estimator

As the song says, Life is a highway. The school board should have been the groups resisting the turn onto the new highway in the first place. They were all over the idea of transitioning to reduced in-person educational model. The positivity rate relates to the number of tests performed and positive results, not the number of sick people relative to the population, and definitely not the number of symptomatic people -- what the people considered sick prior to 2020. They can drive the positivity rate through the roof any time they want. The recent supreme court ruling on this matter in the state of Kentucky lays out explicitly that the state allows the governor to do essentially what ever he wants, with the only possibility being some legislative act to end the state of emergency every other year. And they wouldn't do that with the positivity rate, which they control, remaining through the roof. The COVID 19 Work group, in the county, consists only of people who control the positivity rate. There isn't a single member with a vested interest in a low positivity rate on the council. Tyranny is afoot. Those who don't want their family lines disadvantaged for generations should plan accordingly.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.